Demolition starting for Long Island’s first LGBT affordable housing project

By Augustus Fei and Caitlyn McDuffee

At 34 Park Ave, Bayshore, a brick exterior wall hides the turquoise room with a disco ball hanging from the ceiling. Inside, 30 people are saying goodbye to the place that gave them shelter for 16 years. “This building has been the lifeline for so many…” Samantha Kutcher says. A rainbow flag made of wood panels hangs on the wall behind her, and a sign that reads “Farewell (for now) Bay Shore Center” anticipates a moment that’s been in the making for two years.

On Friday March 22nd, members of the LGBT Network hosted a party to say goodbye to their center in Bay Shore. The 16-year-old structure is being torn this April to make room for 75 units of budget-friendly residential properties, which will be built by the D & F Development Crew, and expected to be ready for use by May of 2020.

“It’s so difficult for a lot of trans people even though we have protections to get affordable housing,” Samantha Kutcher, a member said. “The housing here that they will have available will be a blessing to so many. It will be a clean place to live, a safe place to live, and they will be able to congregate with their own community.”

The housing will be exclusively for LGBT members and people that are LGBT friendly according to Lauren Corcoran, Vice President of External Affairs for the LGBT Network. Attorney Paul Millus, however, believes that the standard will be impossible to regulate.

“LGBT friendly is not a statutory term, you can’t really define it. How friendly do you need to be to be LGBT friendly,” Millus said. “Sexual orientation can not be a standard by which someone gets housing or doesn’t get housing in the state of New York.”

“The housing is just geared toward LGBT friendly people and allies,” Ms. Corcoran clarified. “Anyone can apply for housing there, but it would be well known that the housing is very accepting of the LGBT community, which would probably drive away people who didn’t support [the community] to begin with.”

Board members at the Town of Islip voted unanimously in favor for the project in September of 2017.  The rent for the a unit in the new building is expected to range from $1,000 to $1,600 a month per unit. The average price for renting an apartment in Bay Shore is around $1,715 according to RentCafe, an online listing service to find living rentals.

“We are going to be back here in two years, but where we are going we will be able to grow even more,” President and Chief Director of the organization, David Kilmnick said with tears in his eyes. “We are going to be able to grow even stronger as a community.”  

Several homeowners on the block have already expressed they are welcoming of the new project.

“There are few vacant buildings around here, anything that is going to bring more people and make this street more of a community is a good thing,” resident Justin Haus said, who lives across from the center. “I don’t have any problem with how the building will be LGBT friendly, whoever it is, they will be here and apart of the neighborhood.

The Bay Shore center was first opened in 2002, but the Network has existed since 1993, under the Long Island Gay and Lesbian Youth (LIGALY).

Before closing last week, the center was a location where at least 1000 people per month could go for HIV testing or attend social events for empowerment and support.

“Six years ago I came out as male to female transgender and I didn’t really have anyone to turn to. I found this beautiful place, I will be sad that [the center] is leaving Bay Shore for now,” Emily Iannielli, a member, said.

A new center will be built in Hauppauge for members of the Bay Shore center to continue to meet up and is expected to be four times larger.


About Augustus Fei 3 Articles
I am a journalism major attending Stony Brook University in New York. I want to combine my interests in writing and video games into reporting about video game news. I find it exciting when new games come out and its always interesting to see the trends in games that either keep it popular or sadly start its descent into obscurity. When not focusing on the video game industry, I enjoy dabbling in fantasy writing. While I have my own little fictional world and characters made, I've never had the real confidence to post my works online. Maybe one day I'll find the courage. One day.